Initial thoughts on the Playoff selections

The four teams selected for the College Football Playoff were announced today and unlike last year’s stunning change in the final rankings, this year’s situation produced no such drama. The top 4 of Clemson vs Oklahoma in the Orange Bowl and Alabama vs Michigan State in the Cotton Bowl were exactly the teams everyone expected and as a group, virtually controversy free. That does not mean the rankings weren’t without ramifications though, here are a few initial thoughts:
Good news for the Tide…
Michigan State moving up to #3 provides Alabama with a much more favorable match up for two reasons: 1) Bama brings fans in droves, so they’re not hugely outnumbered regardless of the scenario, BUT a game in Dallas vs nearby Oklahoma would have been the largest crowd for their opponent that Bama would have ever faced in a playoff/BCS title game. 2) Alabama’s few losses in recent years have come against mobile QBs that throw for big numbers. Very good teams that feature a generally pro-style offense, run the ball well and play good defense typically do not defeat the Tide (see LSU the past 4 years). The only team in the playoff that fits the model of a team Alabama usually beats is Michigan State. It’s not surprising that Vegas has initially made the Tide a whopping 11 point favorite.
And more on the Spartans…
Michigan State has given two teams their only loss. Not only is MSU the only team to accomplish the feat this year, it is a rare to happen in any year. But if you look a little closer, it helped MSU, and the Big Ten in general, to have so few games between the better teams. The top 3 teams in the West (Iowa, Northwestern, Wisconsin) only had 1 game against the top 3 teams in the East (Michigan State, Ohio State, Michigan). Given that there could have been up to 9 games between these teams, that leaves 8 games that were unplayed – 8 losses that these teams didn’t have. The West Division teams that MSU played were 2-10 Purdue (MSU won by 3) and 5-7 Nebraska (MSU lost). What if MSU had played Northwestern and Wisconsin in the regular season? Or what if either of these teams had played Ohio State? And Iowa didn’t play Michigan or Ohio State. This is a huge number of losses that didn’t occur, simply because the teams didn’t play. The Big Ten could have easily had no teams in the top 8 and been the conference left out of the playoffs rather than the Pac 12.
Same as it ever was…
the current playoff and New Year’s Six structure is a dramatic improvement from the BCS era, which in spite of the critics, was a dramatic improvement over the previous system (or lack thereof). That said, there are still some remnants from the old bowl system that had a noticeable effect on the quality of the games this year.
The Sugar is tied in to the SEC/Big 12 match-up; this would be great except both conferences did not produce a 2nd Top 10 team. So while #10 North Carolina (Russel Athletic) and #11 TCU (Alamo) are in secondary (at best) bowls, #12 Ole Miss and #16 Oklahoma State are playing in the Sugar.

Georgia Fires Mark Richt – Commentary

The University of Georgia announced today that Mark Richt would be stepping down as head coach after the bowl game. While officially stated as a “mutual decision”, all indications were that Richt wanted to return as head coach next year. As expected, the news was met with a mixed reaction, many acknowledging Richt’s overall high winning percentage with others noting the recent poor record in big games and lack of division titles.

No one wants to see a man lose their job, and by all accounts, Richt was honest, down-to-earth, genuine person and he spends his off time doing charitable and missionary work. But with the very high salary and profile of the Head Coach of a major football program, comes the cold hard facts of the performance on the field. Let’s look at those facts and see why Georgia made the difficult, but correct decision (part 1).

It started great… Richt was phenomenally successful his first eight years as Georgia Head Coach. The bulldogs finished in the AP rankings all 8 years, with 4 top 10 appearances. Georgia had the 6th highest winning percentage in the nation during that time period. True, UGA did not appear in any BCS Title games, but that was more a factor of luck. During those same years, LSU became the first national champion with 2 regular season losses after #2 West Virginia lost to a 4-7 Pitt squad the last week of the season. And Urban Meyer got a title at Florida in 2006 –in order for the Gators to get into the BCS Championship game, #2 USC had to lose to 6-5 UCLA (who would follow up that win by getting blown out in the Walnut Bowl). So no BCS good fortune for Richt, but he had the program rolling.

But the last 6 full seasons (2009-2014) have not been nearly as productive. UGA finished outside the AP Top 25 in half the years, and more notably, is tied for 21St for winning percentage amongst the FBS programs during that time. By comparison, Richt took over when Jim Donnan was fired after the 2000 season. Donnan’s winning percentage ranked 12th in the nation for the previous 4 years, much higher than the ranking of Richt’s program the past 6. Richt was given extra opportunity to turn the program around, and this year was likely the final opportunity. The blow-out loss to Alabama at home was painful, but the bizarre decision on the starting quarterback versus Florida made it appear that Richt was out of answers. And seeing the Gators with a first year coach not just win but dominate the Bulldogs was the last straw for the Georgia administration.

Georgia should never be the 21st best program in the nation. The administration made the difficult first part of the move to improve the program, but now needs to make the 2nd part. Mark Richt was a good hire at that place and time; can they make the right hire this go round?

Should I be worried?

After a weekend filled with upsets, good wins, bad losses, bad wins and good losses, many fan bases are wondering – should I be worried about my team? Mr College Sports is here to answer the question.

 

Auburn – Tigers scored a TD with 40 seconds remaining to tie 1-AA (FCS) Jacksonville State in Jordan-Hare then went on to win in OT 27-20. A shanked punt by Jax State set up AU in great field position to get the tying TD in regulation.
Should I be worried? Yes, yes you should. Jeremey Johnson threw 2 INTs, making 5 on the season, and the Auburn defense had trouble stopping the Gamecock offense (not those Gamecocks, these from the FCS). Meanwhile, the season opening “quality win” over Louisville, was going down the drain as the Cards lost at home to Houston. HC Gus Malzahn expresses his confidence in Johnson, but there isn’t much time for improvement with LSU up next.

Oregon – lost at Michigan State 31-28. Ducks had the ball in Michigan State territory in the last minute of the game but were stopped on 4th down.
Should I be worried? No. QB Vernon Adams was playing in his first game as a Duck against an FBS team and it’s the #6 ranked Spartans on the road. Adams was just a couple plays short of pulling of the huge road win. With Stanford laying an egg in their first game, Ducks are still the big favorite to win the North Division and can win the conference and a spot in the title game with 1 loss.

Tennessee – took a 17 point lead over Oklahoma but lost in double OT on an INT by QB Joshua Dobbs.
Should I be worried? a little; while it’s frustrating to blow the big lead, the Vols did a lot of things right on Saturday night. The defense improved dramatically after allowing 500 yards to Bowling Green the previous week; meanwhile as the Vols were shutting down OU for 3 quarters, Bowling Green destroyed Maryland in College Park. A little concerned that Joshua Dobbs only completed 13 of 31 passes for 125 yards – Vols will need better production than that. But look at the rest of the SEC East – UK had more trouble at home with Louisiana- Lafayette than at South Carolina; UGA has QB issues of their own (see below) and UF and Mizzou struggled with non-power teams at home – the Vols are very much in the race to win the division and make the conference championship game.

Arkansas – two days after HC Bret Bielema criticized Ohio State for playing a weak schedule, including MAC teams, Hogs lose 16-12 to Toledo from the MAC.
Should I be worried? Not as much as you think. The Hogs had over 500 yards total offense but somehow managed to turn that into only 12 points – almost unheard of with only 1 turnover. While the loss will hurt the overall record, the goal of a winning record in the SEC West is still well within reach. The biggest takeaway from this game is sage advice from Motivational Speaker Matt Foley to Bret Bielema “Just shut your BIG YAPPER!”

Notre Dame – Back-up QB DeShone Kizer threw a 40 yard TD pass with 12 seconds left for the Irish to pull-out the 34-27 win over Virginia. Cavs were 5-7 last season and have lost 6 or their last 7 games. Should I be worried? Probably, but it could have been worse. Notre Dame starting QB Malik Zaire is out for the season so Kizer is the starter going forward. Kizer looked good in the short time he played, but the critical fact is that the Irish did not lose to a team likely to finish below .500. If Golden Domers can get the play of Kizer as Ohio State did out of their back-up QBs last year, the playoffs are still a possibility.
Georgia and Florida State – FSU beat South Florida 34-14 after a 7-7 first half; UGA defeated Vandy 31-14 after leading 14-6 at halftime. Each QB struggled early but both 20+ point favorites pulled away in the second half.
Should I be worried? Yes. Both teams feature a graduate transfer QB that won the starting job even after only arriving on campus in mid-summer, suggesting dissatisfaction with QBs already in-house. The two combined for 1 pass completion in the first half of their respective games. Greyson Lambert of Georgia finished 11 of 21 for 116 yards and was briefly replaced by Brice Ramsey. FSU’s Everett Golson ended with 163 yards with a long of only 23. Both teams are still very much in contention in their respective conference divisions, but need a significant improvement in QB/o-line play to beat the better opponents in the future.

What to Watch – Must see games for Saturday, Monday

Saturday
Auburn vs Louisville (Atlanta) 3:30 pm CBS – Can Bobby Petrino pull off the upset of the Tigers who are looking to make a run at the SEC championship and the playoffs? Cards only return 9 starters and Tigers looking for improved defense under new DC Will Muschamp.
BYU at Nebraska 3:30 ABC – Cougars were on a roll last year until QB Taysom Hill was injured; Hill is back and BYU wants to crash the playoffs. Huskers first game with former Oregon State HC Mike Riley, trying to get Big Red back into Big 10 contention.
Texas at Notre Dame 7:30pm NBC – Can the Horns get better QB Play in HC Charlie Strong’s second year? Irish banking on Malik Zaire, the QB in the bowl win over LSU, to reach a spot in the playoffs.
Alabama vs Wisconsin (Dallas) – Bama has played in 5 of these classic games and has dominated each one, but returns only 3 starters on offense and has not named a QB. Grind it out Badger offense will have trouble with the star studded Bama d line.
Monday
Ohio State at Virginia Tech 8:00pm ESPN – Buckeyes are big favorites to repeat as national champions – and open with the team that gave them their only loss in ’14. Beamer’s program has struggled in recent years – will the suspensions of key OSU starters be enough for Hokies to hang around?

What to Watch – Guide to this weekend’s TV viewing

Part 1 – Top Games Thursday and Friday
Thursday
6:00pm ESPN – North Carolina vs South Carolina (Charlotte) – Heels return 18 starters and look for a rare breakout win to kick-off 2015; Cocks trying to prove the Ol Ball Coach still has it in him.
8:30pm FS1 – Michigan at Utah – the Harbaugh era begins at Michigan with a road game against a team that won in the Big House 26-10 last year; is the energy of the new coach enough to pull off an upset right out of the gate?
9:00pm ESPN – TCU at Minnesota – Both TCU and Baylor are in the playoff race, and face embarrassingly easy non-conference schedules… with one exception. This is the Horned Frogs one opportunity to get an out-of-conference win against a Gopher team that is a dark horse contender in the B1G West.

Friday
10:15pm ESPN – Washington at Boise State – Former Boise HC Chris Petersen returns to the smurf turf with a struggling Husky squad.. Will the Broncos welcome back the coach that put the program on the map? Or show no mercy in one of the few games against power 5 teams to make an impression on the playoff committee?

Top 30 Teams for 2015

1 Ohio State The Buckeyes have such an embarrassment of riches that Braxton Miller, a pre-season top Heisman candidate on year ago, is now the 3rd string QB and reportedly will move to WR/HB to add another dimension to the OSU offense. With 16 starters returning from last season’s national championship team, and a schedule with only 1 team that finished ranked in 2014, the Bucks are the biggest favorite to repeat as champions in many years.
2 TCU The Horned Frogs enter 2015 with a chip on their shoulder as the perceived best team in the Big 12 was left out of the inaugural playoffs last season. QB Trevone Boykin threw for a program record 33 TDs in ’14 and returns to operate behind a very experienced offensive line. The defense loses 5 of the team’s 6 top tacklers from last season, including their All American LB Paul Dawson. The net result is probably a repeat of a few shootouts in conference play, but the edge in QB goes to the Frogs in the marquee match-ups.
3 Oregon USC may be getting a lot of buzz for 2015 but the Ducks are the top program in the Pac 12 and are the winningest team in the FBS the last 5 years. The biggest challenge will be to replace Heisman winning QB Marcus Mariota, the 2nd pick in the NFL draft. The expectation is that Vernon Adams, a graduate transfer who put up prolific numbers in the high powered offense at FCS Eastern Washington, will win the starting job. The Ducks only return 12 starters overall, and the defense, which generally played well late in the year, was trampled by Ohio State in the national championship game. But even without Mariota, this is a very athletic, talented team and get’s the slight edge over USC to win the conference and get into the playoffs.
4 Alabama The sky is falling in Tuscaloosa as the Crimson Tide has gone TWO whole years without a national title and hasn’t even appeared in the championship game! If they are to get back to what Roll Tide Nation considers their rightful place, it will be behind a defensive front as good as any in the nation. The elite recruiting classes year after year means the talent is there on offense, but the experience is not. The guess is that former FSU QB Jacob Coker will win the starting QB but he didn’t dominate in the Spring. Every single team in the SEC West has talent and the schedule is one land mine after the other. The history of success even without a lot of returning starters, gives Alabama the slight edge in this deep division.
5 Michigan State The Big Ten is not shy on top flight QBs this season, and Sparty QB Connor Cook may be the top pick in the NFL draft come April 2016. Cook has led MSU to back-to-back major bowl victories and looks to break through with a playoff berth in 2015. Two huge games stand in the way – Oregon at home early, and Ohio State away late. Even just a split of those games could be enough for the Sparty to sneak into the playoffs.
6 Baylor The Bears aren’t going to go quietly even without the services of QB Bryce Petty the 3rd QB taken in the last NFL draft. With an incredible 18 starters returning, including every starter on the offensive and defensive line, this will be a talented team, in the thick of the race for the conference title and a playoff berth. I give the slight edge to TCU based on the more experienced QB, but it’s the Bears that have won 2 straight Big 12 Championships not TCU (or Oklahoma or Texas for that matter). The season likely comes down to the showdown at TCU on Thanksgiving weekend.
7 USC The Trojans are finally back to near full strength as the last of the sanctions have ended, and are poised for their best season since the Pete Carroll era. Leading the way will be QB Cody Kessler who finished 2014 with an amazing 39/5 TD/INT ratio! The men of Troy bring back every starting o-line so a good offense should be even better. Losing Leonard Williams to the NFL from the D line is a big loss, but the younger guys are all highly recruited talented players. The schedule isn’t easy with a non conference trip to Notre Dame and the 2 best teams from the North Division (Oregon and Stanford) are both on the docket. This team will be in the thick of the Pac 12 and playoff race.
8 Georgia The UGA program has underachieved in recent years, ranking as the 9th winningest program in the nation in HC Mark Richt’s first 10 years, falling to 23rd in Richt’s last 5. There is a lot to like about the Dawgs in 2015 and it stars with RB Nick Chubb who had 8 straight 100+ yard rushing games after filling in for the suspended Todd Gurley, and will run behind a very experienced o-line. The defense improved dramatically under 1st year DC Jeremy Pruitt., finishing in the top 20 in the country in total defense. The challenge will be finding a QB as last season’s backup Brice Ramsey battles incoming graduate transfer Greyson Lambert. Lambert lost the starting job at Virginia and arrived at Georgia during the summer. This is a very talented team but the QB situation is a big question. The schedule ramps up as Dawgs face the top two teams from the West Division, Auburn and Alabama in addition to a road game against improving Tennessee.
9 Auburn The Tigers get back a couple of key players, one on offense and one on defense that were lost to injuries in 2014. But the most important addition is new DC Will Muschamp, former HC of the Florida Gators. Even without QB Nick Marshall, a Gus Malzahan offense is going to be good, and QB Jeremiah Johnson is likely a better passer than Marshall. But it’s the D that will make or break the season – the pick here is that Muschamp gets a lot more out of a talented and experienced defense than last year’s results would suggest.
10 Clemson HC Dabo Swinney has taken the Tiger program to heights not seen since the 80s with 4 straight double digit win seasons, 3 consecutive top 15 finishes capped by 3 impressive bowl victories. The top prize – an ACC title – has eluded the Tigers though, thanks mainly to the dominant run Florida State has been on. This season provides the best opportunity for Clemson to unseat the Noles in the division, and it starts with dynamic QB Deshaun Watson. Watson was a big playmaker when healthy last season and will be surrounded by a plethora of talent on offense. Clemson loses 8 starters off the #1 ranked defense in the nation but has the depth to reload rather than rebuild. Tigers get the Noles at home late in the year in what will likely be the division, and maybe conference, defining game.
11 Oklahoma 2014 was a season to forget for the Sooners, one that began with a #4 national ranking and ended with 5 losses, the last, a 40-6 blowout to Clemson in the Russell Athletic Bowl (where OU trailed 40-0 after entering the game a 5 pt favorite). But there is some hope for a rebound. The Sooners have played well when expectations are lower, and the last two 8-win seasons were followed by 11 and 12 win campaigns, so OU has not been down for long under Bob Stoops. Sooners new OC will get more out of QB Baker Mayfield – with an already strong running game, the offense could be really good. Would have been hard to imagine just a couple years ago, but OU is still looking up at TCU and Baylor in the standings.
12 Florida State The Noles sport an eye-popping 27-1 record over the last two years, but a huge amount of that talent is now in the NFL. The program set a record by having a player at every offensive position go in last spring’s NFL draft. The rebuilding starts at QB where transfer Everette Golson from ND will battle Jr Sean Maguire. Whomever wins the starter’s job will operate behind an oline with 1 starter back and without the team’s top 2 pass catchers. Before you feel too sorry for the Noles though, HC Jimbo Fisher has brought in a ton of 4 and 5 star recruits, just waiting to take their place on the field. This is still a talented team, but look for a dropoff from the last 2 seasons.
13 Notre Dame The Irish looked every bit the playoff contender in the nail biting loss at Florida State, but then injuries and turnovers sent the team into a late season downward spiral. Optimism abounds though for a playoff run in 2015 thanks to 17 returning starters, including the then Fr QB that started the bowl win over LSU. That Fr, Malik Zaire, can run in addition to passing and will operate behind a more experienced o-line. The D has almost everybody back… but back from a unit that gave up 43 points in the loss to Northwestern and 49 to USC. This is a talented team with a manageable schedule, but not sure the defense will be good enough for a playoff berth.
14 Arizona State The Nomadic Todd Graham may have found his home in Tempe, leading the Sun Devils to back to back 10 win seasons for the first time since the old WAC days of the 70s. ASU will be categorized as a team not returning their starting QB, but a bit of semantics as last season’s “back-up” Mike Bercovici played several games when Taylor Kelly was injured. Bercovici finished with a higher completion percentage and led the team to wins over USC and Stanford. With 9 starters back on D, the goal is to keep up the sack machine and limit the big plays. In a strong division of a deep conference, ASU will have a say in the Pac 12 championship race.
15 Mississippi In spite of a dropoff late in the year that ended with a blowout loss in the Peach Bowl, 2014 was a break through season for the Rebels, highlighted by the upset win over Alabama. The eye-popping recruiting class that HC Hugh Freeze brought in finally showed on the field especially with a defense that went from allowing 28 pts/game in 2012 to 16 in 2014. Those big playmakers on D are back for this year, maybe their last before moving to the NFL, so this year needs to count. The Rebels return a lot of starters on the ofense too and would be picked much higher in the rankings if they weren’t losing their experienced QB. If the Rebs get better than expected play from a new QB, then this team will make a legitimate run at their first ever appearance in the SEC Championship Game.
16 UCLA An overall successful yet roller coaster season in 2014, where behind QB Brett Hundley (5th QB taken in NFL draft) led the Bruins to a 10 win year and a bowl win over K-State. The season was highlighted by the blowout win over crosstown rival USC but an odd mix of quality wins (Arizona State, Arizona) was offset by the drubbing at the hands of Stanford and a 2OT escape of hapless Colorado. Everybody is back in 2015 – except the most important player Hundley. The new QB will have a lot of familiar faces around him, but it will be hard to repeat Hundley’s numbers. The lack of the experienced QB is the only piece standing between the Bruins and a division or conference title.
17 Georgia Tech The Tech program had been stuck in neutral for several years, with decent records and bowl trips, but typically ending the season with a loss to rival Georgia and finishing unranked. The jackets broke out of their funk in a big way in 2014 with a top 10 ranking, a huge victory over the hated Dawgs and an impressive beatdown of the SEC”s 2nd best team in the Orange Bowl. HC Paul Johnson has what he most needs – a QB that may not look that impressive standing next to you, but that can run that triple option offense to perfection. Two big challenges face the Techsters to repeat last season’s success: 1) while QB Justin Thomas is back, almost everyone else that touched the ball is not and 2) the defense was barely in the top 80 in total D but made up for it by forcing a ton of turnovers. The same defense without the TOs is not a good one. A tougher schedule also makes 2014’s record hard to repeat, but the offense should still give all opposing D coordinators fits.
18 LSU The only thing worse than ending the season in the Music City Bowl for a program like LSU’s is to end the season with a loss in the Music City Bowl. The 8-5 final record was the worst since the same 8-5 record in 2008. There is some hope for a rebound in 2015 as the Tigers bring back more starters than usual to a program that typically loses a lot of underclassmen to the NFL. LSU will feature one of the top RBs in FBS In So Leonard Fournette, important in their run oriented offense. The Tigers return 6 starters on defense and should once again have one of the top secondaries in the nation. The big challenge once again will be at the QB position – LSU finished #114 in passing offense in 2014 and doesn’t appear to be heading towards any kind of breakout in 2015. While this is a very talented team, the question mark at QB and the loss of long time DC John Chavis to Texas A&M keep the expectations in check.
19 Boise State The Broncos ended last year where they remain in the hearts of most college football fans – with an upset over a Power 5 team in the Fiesta Bowl. Boise returns 17 starters from that squad, including the entire o-line and a number of playmakers on the D. The challenge is that the two biggest stars on last seasons team QB Grant Hedrick and RB Jay Ajayi are gone and an incumbent QB has not been identified. Nearly 80 teams went to bowls last season, but Boise only plays 5 of them, so a very good record is assured, but not enough quality wins to warrant a high ranking.
20 Wisconsin That smell in the air isn’t just bratwurst on the grill, it’s change; as in the stunning move HC Gary Andersen made when he left the Badgers for a seemingly lower profile program at Oregon State. In comes Paul Chryst from Pitt who will attempt to keep the strong running game and improve the passing attack. Badgers should have another stout D but do lose 3 starters on the o-line; plus the biggest loss – RB Melvin Gordon, a 1st round NFL draft pick. Only one team on the schedule that was ranked last year should result in a good record and even with coaching change and rebuilding o-line, the opportunity to get pummeled in the Big Ten Championship game is well within reach.
21 Tennessee Expectations are Smoky Mountain High after the bowl victory over Iowa last year gave the Vols a winning season for the first time since 2009. Tennessee returns 18 starters, the most in the SEC and features an exciting QB in Josh Dobbs that can make big plays with his hands or feet. There is talent around Dobbs at the skill positions but the o-line struggled mightily in 2014 – although now much more experienced than that group at the start of last season. The defense returns 5 of the 6 leading tacklers from a unit that finished in the Top 40 in the nation in total D. The schedule includes games at Alabama and a big non-conference showdown in Knoxville vs Oklahoma, but the Vols are realistically in the SEC East race and have a good chance to finish in the rankings for the first time since ’07.
22 Penn State Often the 1st year of a new coaching regime shows only modest improvement, then it’s the 2nd year that the program makes a big jump. James Franklin, after unbelievable success at perennial doormat Vanderbilt, is in just that position with the Nittany Lions. PSU features a solid defense and a talented QB in Christian Hackenberg who spent most of 2014 running for his life. WIth a more experienced QB is great, the more experience o-line is what will make a difference. Add in a very easy non-conference schedule, and the Lions have a good chance to finish in the rankings for the first time since 2009.
23 Stanford The Cardinal look to rebound from a disappointing season, the first in 5 years without double digit wins and it was the offense mostly to blame. QB Kevin Hogan returns as a 5th year Senior and could put up big numbers behind a very experienced oline. The defense does have some rebuilding to do too, losing 4 players to the NFL draft, but the Cardinal usually has some talent around for the D. Most of the tough conference games are at home, so Stanford has a good shot to get back into the rankings for 2015.
24 Arkansas Few teams were hotter than the Hogs at the end of 2014, following up the upset win over LSU with the 30 pt shellacking of then #8 Ole Miss; the late season rallied was capped by a dominant bowl win over Texas. Expectations are running high this year, with a big, experienced o-line, 2 1000 yd rushers, and a Sr QB among 9 starters back on offense. The defense finished #10 in the nation last year, but does lose their top player at LB and on the D-line. The challenge for Arkansas is that upward movement in the SEC West is difficult, and with great RB’s and oline last season, the Hogs were just 2-6 in conference. Still, I expect the success of late 2014 to carry over into 2015 and a return to the Top 25 is possible.
25 Virginia Tech It’s hard to believe that the Hokies finished tied for last in their division and needed a bowl win just to barely finish over .500. The good news is that VA Tech appears primed for a big comeback season in 2015. The optimism starts with the defensive line which should be the best in the conference and improve upon what was already a top 15 scoring defense. The problems have been on offense, but with increased stability on the o-line, and a more experienced QB in former Texas Tech starter Michael Brewer the pieces are coming together for a much better offense. Throw in a schedule that allows the Hokies to skip Clemson, FSU and Louisville from the other division, a run at the division, and even conference title, are quite possible.
26 Missouri It’s that time of year where we again underrate the Missouri Tigers, the defending SEC East Champions for 2 years in a row. Last season, Mizzou was blown out at home by Georgia after already losing at home to lowly Indiana, and the season looked over… but 6 straight SEC wins had the Tigers back in the conference championship game once again. The Tigers only bring back 12 starters, although that includes QB Matty Mauk. Mauk is one of the grizzled veterans among SEC QBs and reportedly was in great shape at Spring practice, working to improve on his 2013 performance. The defense losses a lot of talent including Shane Ray, but does return their top 2 tacklers from a D that was #19 in scoring defense last season. The pick here is that Missouri still has a solid team on both sides of the ball, but may not beat other conference teams (Arkansas, Tennessee) that are improving.
27 Arizona The Wildcats were the surprise winners of the Pac 12 South last year and will be in the race once again. Arguably the most important player to the team is superstar LB Scooby Wright who can make plays all over the field. QB Anu Solomon led all freshmn Qbs with nearly 3800 yards passing and should be a more consistent good decision maker in his 2nd year. Cat’s pulled a lot of games out of their butts last season, the ball likely wont quite bounce their way as often.
28 OK State Five straight losses late in the season had sent the team into a terrible downward spiral, but an upset of rival OU and win over Washington in the Cactus Bowl has the team primed for improvement in 2015. QB Mason Randolph had his redshirt taken off with only 3 games remaining but he played well and is the hope for a big rebound for the team this season. The rest of the offense is talented and experienced and are ready for 2014. The defense is the bigger question mark, but is much more experienced going into this year than last. With cupcake non-conference schedule and many of the key Big 12 games at home, the ‘Pokes can get back on track after a disappointing 2014.
29 Texas A&M The 2014 season began with a bang for the Aggies, demolishing #9 South Carolina in Columbia; but ended with a whimper, 5 losses in the last 7 regular season games, including a 59-0 shellacking at the hands of Alabama. A program in flux in 2014 still has a lot of talent but also a lot of questions. The QB that led the team to the huge win over the Gamecocks has left the program, leaving behind So. Kyle Allen, who did lead the team to the biggest win of the year over Auburn. But it’s the other side of the ball where the work really needs to be done, after finishing #102 in total defense. So HC Kevin Sumlin brought in LSU’s well respected DC John Chavis to remake the defense – not sure how much improvement will happen in year 1. A&M remains a program with a lot of talented athletes, but in a division where literally every team is good, it will be a dogfight each week.
30 Nebraska HC Bo Penini lead the Huskers for 7 years but although the team was never bad, he couldn’t get the program over the hump into the upper echlon of the Big Ten and was fired. New HC Mike Riley takes over from Oregon State and has some talent to work with. The D lost it’s star in DE Randy Gregory but does return most of the rest of the D line. The excitement though is on the other side of the ball where Riley was known for high powered offenses and has an experience QB to work with. Huskers do have a couple tough games in the non-conference schedule with BYU and Miami, but are in the weaker Western Divsion of the Big Ten. Badgers are the favorite, but Huskers are definitely in the race for the Division.

Weekend Rewind – August 30

Some quick thoughts on the games of the first weekend of the college football season

 

Dominant Wins

Texas A&M was stunning in the 52-28 demolition of South Carolina; the Gamecocks coming off an 11-2 season. The Aggies offense was unstoppable and QB Kenny Hill looked like a polished veteran, throwing for over 500 yards and no INTs. A&M easily had the most impressive performance of the weekend.

Georgia was tied with Clemson at half by the same score as last year; the final results were very different as the Dawgs unleashed Todd Gurley – 198 yards rushing in addition to the 100 yard kickoff return for a TD leading to a 45-21 win.

Survivors

UCLA scored 3 defensive TDs and needed them all to escape Charlottesville with a 28-20 win over Virginia, 2-20 in 2013. Bruins o-line really struggled although the noon Eastern Time games are always difficult for West Coast teams.

Alabama had their hands full with West Virginia, 4-8 last year. Mountaineer QB Clint Tricket threw for over 350 yards but numerous drops by his WR’s at key times cost WVU a chance at the big upset.

I’ll take it

Penn State, FSU and LSU all won close games over teams that had great records last year. Penn State got a last second field goal to edge Central Florida (12-1 in 2013) in Dublin, Ireland. Back at the ranch (Jerry’s) in Dalas, OK State (10-3 last season0 got several big plays running and passing from QB JT Walsh, but FSU got one more from Jameis Winston and Rashad Green to hold off the upset minded Pokes 37-31. And just across the state of Texas in Houston, LSU trailed Wisconsin (9-4 in 2013) 24-7 in the 3rd quarter, but big plays on both sides of the ball in the 4th gave the Tigers the 28-24 win.

This is no way to start a season

Houston opened their brand new on campus stadium by getting throttled by Texas-San Antonio 27-7. This is the Roadrunners first season as a full member of FBS after transitioning from FCS. UTSA can compete for a bowl appearance for the first time in school history.

Vanderbilt lost HC James Franklin and many of his recruits in the offseason, then opened this year with a 37-7 face plant at the hands of Temple in Nashville. The Owls were 2-10 in 2013  which included losses to Fordham and Idaho. Vandy finished 9-4 and ranked in the top 25 last season but that seems a distant memory.

Northwestern was looking forward to a season that maybe with better health could turn into something special in the Big 10s new West Division; this in spite of a bizarre offseason with the vote by the players to start a union. If they had actually been paid employees, they would have all been fired after losing at home to Cal. The Bears snapped a 10 game losing streak after finishing 1-11 in 2013, 0-11 against FBS teams.

 

 

About the Forecast Top 25

SEE Top 25 BELOW

This is not intended to be a power ranking but a forecast of the final AP Top 25. The rankings here assume that the 4 teams that make the playoff will finish in the top 4 of the final poll.

Feel free to leave a comment if you agree or disagree!

Forecast Top 25 for 2014

1 Alabama Nick Saban will have the Tide hungry after the disappointing end to ’13; the strong oline and RBs will be enough to offset inexperience under center. Tide has won 2 nat’l titles with 1st year QBs.
2 FSU Returning Heisman winner Winston will operate behind all Sr o-line. Defense loses key players and 3rd DC in 3 years a challenge as is the tendency towards complacency after a championship; but talent and schedule give the Noles a chance to make another run.
3 Oklahoma Sooners ended ’13 on a high note, beating rival OK State and heavily favored Bama in the Sugar Bowl. If QB Knight can play as he did against the Tide, the Sooners will be in contention for the playoff berth.
4 Auburn Auburn returns 14 starters from last season’s BCS titlist runner-ups; schedule is tougher and they did lose a few key players. The 2nd year of a Gus Malzahn offense will be hard for opponents to stop
5 Oregon Mariota is also at the top of the list of favorites for the Heisman and will operate behind an experienced o-line; Ducks are focused on becoming more physical but lose longtime DC Allotti. Can Mariota stay healthy and can the Ducks get past their nemesis Stanford?.
6 UCLA Another great QB in Hundley leads 17 returning starters for the Bruins. Jim Mora has done a great job turning UCLA around – the challenge is a tough schedule that could include two games with Oregon.
7 South Carolina These are heady days for the Gamecocks, finishing in the top 10 three straight years. Steve Spurrier has a very experienced team that had a great chance to make it 4.
8 Michigan State Quite a finish for the Spartans in ’13, following the upset of Ohio State in the conference champ game with the victory over Stanford in the Rose Bowl. One of the few top teams where the defense was the strength and a number of starters have departed. Schedule is friendly though and MSU will be in contention for the Big 10 title.
9 Baylor Another top 10 team, another great QB, this time it’s the Bear’s Petty. Baylor should continue with the point a minute offense, but defense remains the Achilles heel. Still another double digit winning season for a team that’s fun to watch.
10 Ohio State Buckeyes were a top 4 pick before QB Miller was lost for year; overall talent still high and a strong D keeps Bucks in Top 10 and Big 10 race, but playoff chances took a big hit.
11 Iowa Hawkeyes have 13 starters returning including including a stable of RBs and an experienced QB. But it’s what they don’t have this will be important: no OSU, MSU, Michigan or Penn St on the schedule and no road games against the top teams in their division (Nebraska and Wisconsin come to Iowa City)
12 LSU Tigers were only team in SEC history to have a 3000 yd passer, two 1000 yd receivers and a 1000 yd rusher; all are gone in 2014. But Les Miles has recruited phenomenally well and has produced in the past after sending a lot of talent to the NFL.
13 Stanford 4 straight 11 or more win seasons have set an incredibly high bar for an exceptional academic private school. HC Shaw will continue his theme of a physical run oriented offense and a defense that will hit you in the mouth (which has been the recipe for beating Oregon). This squad is less experienced and faces a brutal schedule so 11 wins again will be harder to come by.
14 Wisconsin A intriguing team these Badgers coming in to 2014; 2nd year HC’s frequently do well, yet Wisky only returns 10 starters. But one of those is RB Gordon, maybe the best in the nation north and west of Athens, GA. They don’t have 4 of their top 5 tacklers from last season, but they also don’t have Ohio State, MSU, Penn St or Michigan on the schedule. Certainly one of the favs in the West.
15 Georgia After beginning the season #5 numerous injuries and a porous D, UGA finished unranked. Even without QB Murray though, there’s hope in Dawg nation with RB Gurley back healthy, and new DC Pruitt from FSU to quickly improve the defense. Dawgs are definite contenders in the East.
16 Clemson Clemson winning with defense? Could be the story in ’14! Offense will drop off without their 2 superstars QB Boyd and WR Watkins but should still be solid. The defense may be the strength of the team and HC Swinney has loaded up on top recruits in recent years. A tough schedule will make it hard to match last season’s win total, but a solid season nonetheless.
17 USC Extreme highs and lows for the Trojans in ’13 from a home loss to Wash St to a win over then #5 Stanford ended with 10 wins and a top 20 ranking. New HC Sarkisian returns to where he was OC during the glory years after rebuilding Washington. The scholarship sanctions have resulted in limited depth, so injuries could be a big factor; but the talent is there and Washington and Oregon are not (on the schedule).
18 Florida Could not have been much worse for the Gators with injuries and an ineffective offense leading to the worse record since ’79. New OC Roper from Duke, and better health, brings hope to the offense and a still salty defense means a big turnaround is within sight.
19 Kansas State A rebuilding year for the Wildcats ended on a strong note with a blowout bowl win over Michigan. K-State only returns 11 starters but that’s more than last year, and HC Bill Snyder seems to always pull an upset or two. Schedule is tougher – 3rd game last year was UMass; this season it’s Auburn!
20 Texas The Charlie Strong era began at UT with Strong running off a bunch of players – not necessarily a bad thing from an underachieving team. Strong is highly respected and should turn things around, the question is how quick. Improved QB play would sure help, but starting QB Ash has been injury prone. Expect defense to play with more intensity right away. A bowl win could get the Horn’s into the final top 25.
21 Mississippi If Huge Freeze is to avoid the nickname “Mr February”, now is the time to turn that success on the recruiting front to a top 25 finish on the field. Reb’s return one of the few experienced passers in the SEC and feature 9 returning starters on D, including mega recruit Robert Nkemdiche. Less than 9 wins would be a disappointment.
22 Notre Dame Big story for Irish was supposed to be the return of QB Golson, but now it’s turned more unpleasant with reports of academic irregularities and several key players suspended. Golson makes a big difference on this team, but his talents will be muted by the loss of the suspended players and a very tough schedule that includes trips to USC, Arizona State and FSU.
23 Oregon State Beavers were a surprise pick in ’13 and they surprised me by opening with a home loss to FCS Eastern Washington. But with 14 starters back, including QB Mannion – he threw for over 4600 yards last season and will likely knock off Matt Barkley as the conferences’ all time passing yardage leader. Schedule isn’t easy, but if they can go 3-0 in OOC play, an upset here or there would result in a 9 win season.
24 Louisville Cards finished 12-1 in ’13, but the big story is the return of former HC Bobby Petrino. UL loses 1st round draftee in QB Bridgewater, but while Petrino may lack any kind of moral fiber, he has been a phenomenally successful college coach. Cards to play a tougher schedule with move to the ACC, but look for a solid debut.
25 Cincinatti Bearcats went 9-3 last season and return 13 starters, although not their QB. Notre Dame transfer Gunner Keil looked good in the spring game, but the big plus is the schedule: no UCF and Houston and ECU come to Cincy.